0LW6WHFNHUDXVJHVWDWWHWH*HUlWHGUIHQQXULQYRUVFKULIWVPlLJ
DQJHEUDFKWHJHHUGHWH6WHFNGRVHQJHVWHFNWZHUGHQ
(VPXVVHLQDOOSROLJHU7UHQQVFKDOWHUPLWPLQGHVWHQV PP.RQ
WDNWDEVWDQGDQJHEUDFKWZHUGHQDXHUEHL$QVFKOXVVDQHLQHIUHL
]XJlQJOLFKH6WHFNGRVH
8PVWHOOXQJDXIHLQHDQGHUH*DVDUW
:HQQGLHHLQVFKOlJLJHQ%HVWLPPXQJHQGHVMHZHLOLJHQ/DQGHV
GLHVHUODXEHQNDQQGLHVHV*HUlWDXIDQGHUH*DVDUWHQXPJHVWHOOW
ZHUGHQVLHKH7\SHQVFKLOG'LHKLHUIUQRWZHQGLJHQ7HLOHEHILQ
GHQ VLFK LP PLWJHOLHIHUWHQ 8PEDXNLW MH QDFK 0RGHOO RGHU N|QQHQ
EHUGHQ.XQGHQGLHQVWEH]RJHQZHUGHQ
:,&+7,*%ULQJHQ6LHGHQ$XINOHEHUPLWGHUXPJHVWHOOWHQ*DVDUW
LQGHU1lKHGHV7\SHQVFKLOGHVDQ
(VPVVHQIROJHQGH6FKULWWHEHIROJWZHUGHQ
$$XVWDXVFKGHU'VHQ$EE
$OOH5RVWH%UHQQHUGHFNHOXQG9HUWHLOHUDEQHKPHQ
'LH'VHQPLWGHP6FKOVVHODXVWDXVFKHQGHUEHUXQVHUHQ
WHFKQLVFKHQ 6HUYLFH PLW GHP &RGH IU GRSSHOIODPPLJH
%UHQQHUYHUIJEDULVW6LHKH7DEHOOH$EE (VLVW
EHVRQGHUVGDUDXI]XDFKWHQGDVVVLFKGLH'VHEHLGHU
$EQDKPHRGHU%HIHVWLJXQJQLFKWDEO|VW8PGLH'LFKWLJNHLW]X
JHZlKUOHLVWHQPVVHQVLHIHVWDQJH]RJHQVHLQ
%HLGLHVHQ%UHQQHUQLVWNHLQH5HJXOLHUXQJGHU3ULPlUOXIWHUIRU
GHUOLFK
'LH 'VHQ XQG %UHQQHUGHFNHO DQ GHQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ %UHQQHUQ
EHIHVWLJHQ$XHUGHPVLQGGLH5RVWHHQWVSUHFKHQGDQ]XEULQ
JHQ
%(LQVWHOOXQJGHU*DVKlKQH
=XU(LQVWHOOXQJGHU*DVKlKQHPXVVGLH$EGHFNXQJGHV*DVNRFK
IHOGHVGHPRQWLHUWXQGGLH(OHNWURQLNNDUWHDEJHQRPPHQZHUGHQ
'HPRQWDJHGHU$EGHFNXQJ
$OOH5RVWH%UHQQHUGHFNHO9HUWHLOHUXQG%HGLHQNQHEHODEQHK
PHQ
'LH6FKUDXEHQGHU%UHQQHUO|VHQ
%HL%HGDUIGHQ'HPRQWDJHKHEHOYHUZHQGHQGHUEHU
XQVHUHQ.XQGHQGLHQVWHUKlOWOLFKLVW0LWKLOIHGHV+HEHOVGLHYRU
GHUH &OLSEHIHVWLJXQJ DQ GHQ DQJH]HLJWHQ 6WHOOHQ O|VHQ $EE
$EGHFNXQJYRUVLFKWLJDEQHKPHQ
'HPRQWDJHGHU(OHNWURQLNNDUWH$EE
'LH(OHNWURQLNNDUWHLVWGXUFK%HIHVWLJXQJVVWLIWHDQGHQ6HLWHQ
XQGLQGHU0LWWHDQGHU+DOWHUXQJEHIHVWLJW9RUVLFKWLJDXIGLH
%HIHVWLJXQJVVWLIWHGUFNHQRKQHGLHVH]XEHVFKlGLJHQ:HQQ
HLQ6WLIWEULFKWPXVVGLHJHVDPWH+DOWHUXQJDXVJHWDXVFKWZHU
GHQ
'DEHLLVWIROJHQGHUPDHQYRU]XJHKHQ
'LH6WLIWHDXIGHUHLQHQ6HLWHO|VHQ
'LH PLWWOHUHQ 6WLIWH O|VHQ 'D]X PLW GHQ )LQJHUQ DXI EHLGHQ 6HLWHQ
GUFNHQ
'LH6WLIWHDXIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHO|VHQXQGGLH(OHNWURQLNNDUWH
DEQHKPHQ
$FKWXQJ
'LH(OHNWURQLNNDUWHYRUVLFKWLJKDQGKDEHQ$QWLVWDWLN6FKXW]YHU
ZHQGHQRGHU(OHNWURQLNNDUWHDQGHQ5lQGHUQDQIDVVHQ1LH
PDOV2EHUIOlFKHQPLW.RPSRQHQWHQRGHU%DKQHQEHUKUHQ
'LH ]\OLQGULVFKHQ 7HLOH XQG )HGHUQ LP 6FKDIW GHV *DVKDKQV HQW
IHUQHQ
5HJXOLHUXQJGHV%\SDVVHV$EE
6LHKH7DEHOOH$EE %\SDVVVFKUDXEHQ 0EHL%HGDUIPLW
KLOIHHLQHV7RU[6FKUDXEHQGUHKHUVDQSDVVHQ$EE
$'LH%\SDVVVFKUDXEHQPVVHQIHVWDQJH]RJHQZHUGHQ
%'LH%\SDVVVFKUDXEHQPVVHQEQGLJPLWGHU)DVVXQJ
DEVFKOLHHQ
6WHOOHQ6LHVLFKHUGDVVEHLP'UHKHQGHV%HGLHQNQHEHOV]ZL
VFKHQ GHU K|FKVWHQ XQG GHU QLHGULJVWHQ 6WXIH GHU %UHQQHU QLFKW
DXVJHKWXQGHVQLFKW]XHLQHP)ODPPHQUFNVFKODJNRPPW
0RQWDJHGHU(OHNWURQLNNDUWHXQGGHU$EGHFNXQJ
,QHQWJHJHQJHVHW]WHU5HLKHQIROJHGHU'HPRQWDJHYHUIDKUHQ
1LHPDOVGLH*DVKDKQDFKVHGHPRQWLHUHQ,P)DOOHHLQHU
%HVFKlGLJXQJGHU.RPSRQHQWHQGHV*DVKDKQHVGLHVHQHUVHW
]HQ
.DOLEULHUXQJGHU(OHNWURQLN
6REDOGGDV*HUlWHUQHXWPRQWLHUWLVWGLH.DOLEULHUXQJGHU(OHNW
URQLNHQWVSUHFKHQGGHU$EELOGXQJGXUFKIKUHQ
1LHPDOVGLH*DVKDKQDFKVHGHPRQWLHUHQ,P)DOOHHLQHU
%HVFKlGLJXQJPXVVGHU*DVKDKQNRPSOHWWDXVJHWDXVFKWZHU
GHQ
el
Ù
̯͉̻̓͆͂̾̈́͐̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆͐
̨͏͇͇͓͔͍͇͓͆́͐͋̓͗̾͋̓
῭͈̻͈͎͕́͑͒̈́͒͐̓͆͂̾̈́͐͏̽͑͆͐͏͈͌͏͎͕͗͏͉̻̽͑̈́͒̈́͑͒͆͌̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆
͉͈͕̀͏͓͉͓̽͑͆͒͆͐͑͑̈́̽͐
̯͈͈͉͚͎͓͓̻̈́͌̈́͐͏͕͎͓͓̼͈͎͈͚͎͈͉͈͉̼͌͑̀͒͐͒͐̓͆͂̾̈́͐̈́̾͌̀͋͌̈́͌̓̈́͒͐
̲͕͔͇͖͔͕͓͇͌̓̓͌̓̀͆͏͇͎͇͖͗̿͒͋͌̓́̓͊͞͏͉̓͏͇͆͏
͍͖͉̓͌͑͑͊͊͑͞͏͉͇͓͕͖͑͋͑͆́͑̓͒͝ͅ͏͕͓͇͇͖͑͋͒͋͆́͑͘ͅ
̧͓͉͓͓͑͑̈́̽̀͒̽͏̼͈͕̈́͌̀͏͈͎͎͈͈͚͎͆͑͋̈́̾͒̀͋͌͑̈́̀̈́͏͈͚͎͓͋̈́͌͐ͅ
͕͜͏͎͓͐¨̈́͌͏̼͈͓͇̼͎͕̼͓̈́͌̀͑͌̓̈́̈́̾͑̈́͌̀͑͛͑͒͆͋̀̀͒̈́͑͆͐
͉͓̀͑̾͋͗͌
̡͍͇͓͇͔͇͓͇͕͔͕͔͉͓͔͑͋͒̓́͌̓̾̓͞ͅͅ͏͇͔͉͓͎͔͉͓͆͒͊͋͌̓͋͞
͔͎͓͒͑̓͒͑̀ͅ ͔͇ ͍͍͖̾͑ ͕͖͑͞ ͇͖̓͒́͑ ͊̓ ͇͒̿͋ ͏̓ ́ͅ͏͖͑͏ ̓͝
͇͖͔͕͉͎͐͑͋͑͆͑̿͏͕͇͑͘͏͔͎͚͋͌͗͝͞͏͎͇͕͉̓͏͔͖͔͎͔͉͋͑̓͒͊͋͘͞͞
͌̓͋͏͎͇͔͕͖͓͑͑͊́̓͌̓͋͑͌̓͏͑͏͔͎͓͕͚͋͑͞͏͕͑͋͌͟͏͇͕̓͋͒͋͟͏
͆͋̓͏͎͓͉͍͇͕͇͖̬͕͇͉͎͔͉͇͑̀͌͒͋͌͑͌̓͋̓͒́͑͆͋̓́͒̿͗̓͒̿͋͞͏̓
͇͆͑͊́ ͔͕͓͋ ͕͇͓͆͋̓̾͐͋ ͖͑ ͇͎͈͗̓͒͑͝͏͕̓͋ ͔͇͕͋͌̾͘ ͎͇ ͕͑͏ ͇͔͎̓͒͋͝
̵͖͏͔͕͕́̓̓͋͏͇̓͋͌͑͋͏͚͏̶͔͇͕͇͎͇͕͇̀͑͘͏̵͓͕͉͋͌̿͒̈́͋͋̓͝ͅ͏
͔͎͔͇͍͍͖͕͖͇͖͒͑̓͒͑̀̾͑͑̓͒́͑͞ͅ
̢͓͓͉͓̼͕͈͕͈͚͎͈͎͈͉͈͉͕͒̽͆͑͑̈́̽̈́͑̈́̓̀͑͒̈́̾͋͌͂̀̀̽͏̽͑͆
͎̀̀͂͏͈͎̈́͛̈́͒̀͆̈́͋͏͈͉͈͉͕̽̽̈́̀͂͂̈́͊͋̀͒̽͏̽͑͆͒͆͐¨͎̈́͌͋͏̈́̾
͈͉̻͓͓͉͓͈͌̀͂̾͌̈́̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆̀͒̽͐͒͆͐͑͑̈́̽͐͑̈́͂͗͒̽͒͏̧͎͕͚͈͑͒̀
̈́͂͂͛͆͑͆ ͈͕͈͑͛̈́ ͚͎͋͌ ͔͚͎̈́͑͌ ͆ ͓͉͓͑͑̈́̽ ͕͏͈͎͎͈͈͆͑͋̈́̾͒̀ ͈͂̀ ͎͒͌ ͚͎͊͂
͎͓̼͕͈͕͈̈́͑̈́̓̀͑͒̈́̾
̰͏͈͉̻̼͍͈͓̼͎͈͌͒͆͌̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆̈́͊͂͒̈́̀͌̈́̾͌̀͑͋́̀͒͐͏͓͇͈͋̾͑̈́͐
͎͈͉͈͎͒̽͐̓̀͌͋̽͐͋̈́͒͆͏͇͈͓͉͓͎͓͛͋͑͆͒͆͐͑͑̈́̽͐̀͌̀͂͏̻͔͈̈́͒̀
͈͉̼͕͑͒͆͌̈́͒͒̀̀͏͉̀͒͆͏͈͈͉͎͈͉͎̼͈͑͒͌͂͌̈́̀̀̈́͜͏͎͓͉͈͈͕̾̀̾̈́͑͆͐͑͛͐
̻͒͑͆
̳͒͋͏͕͇͇̓͑͑͋̓͆̀͑͝͏͇͙͕͇͕͉̿͒͋̓͆͋̓͌͝ͅ͏͉͍͇͕͌͒͋͌̀
͕͔͕͕͉͓͔͖͔͇͖͓͒͑͗͑͆͑́̓͌̓͋͑̓̿͒͋͑͌̀
̳͎͉͈͎̀͊̓͒͜͏͎͔͎͎̓͑̾̀͐͏̼͈͈̈́͌̀̈́̾͌̀͑͒̈́͏̼͎͎̼͈͎̈́͗͋͌͑͒͊
͎͔͈͔͇͑͒̈́͌̀̀̈́͛͂̈́͒̀͆̈́̀̽͋̈́͒̀̈́͜͏̻͎͓͔͎͋͑͆͋̈́̾̀͒͛͏͎͓͌̽
̻͈͒͆͐́͑͆͐̈́͑͒͌͜
̯͈͓͉͓̼͉͑͑̈́͐͋̈́͆͊̈́͒͏͈͉̽͒͏͎͔͎͎̓͑̾̀͏̼͈͈͎͈̈́͌̀͂̈́͌͌͒̀͜
͓͎͕͏͈͉̻̈́͗͒
̬͆͌͒͏͎͎͎͈͎̈́̾͒̈́͒̈́͑͗͒̈́͏͈͉͚͓͉͓̲͒͆͐͑͑̈́̽͐̈́̈́͏̾͒͗͑͆
̻͉͉̼͎͕͈͉͚̼̀͌͂͆͐̀͊͑͒̈́͒͒̈́͌͋̀͐͑͏͈́͐
̳͒͋͏͕͉̓͝͏͇͕͔͕͔͉͌̓̾̓ͅ
̢͓͓͉͓͈͎͈͕͉͎͒̽͆͑͑̈́̽̀͌͒͑͒̈́̾͑͒͆͌̀͒͆͂͏͔͎̾̀͑͛͋͗͌̀͋̈́͒͌
͉͎͈͚̀͌͌͑͋ (1 ͈͂̀ ͓͉͓̼͑͑̈́͐ ̀̈́͏͎͓̾ ͓͉͓͑͑̈́̽ ͎͈͕͈̼̈́͌͒͑͋͌͆ ͑̈́
̼͈͎͊
̳͎ ̼͈͎͊ ͎͑͒ ͎͎͎̾ ͈͂̾͌̈́͒̀ ͆ ͉̻̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆ ͒͆͐ ͓͉͓͑͑̈́̽͐ ͏̼͈̈́ ͌̀
͈͉̻̈́̾͌̀̀͒͊͊͆͊̀͑͒̈́͏̼͎͉͈͇̈́͗͋͌̀͑͒̀̈́͏͚
̳̀ ̼͈͊̀ ͉͎̻͌͒ ͑͒͆ ͓͉͓͑͑̈́̽ ͒̀ ͎͓͊͑͒͏͈͉̻͗͋̀͒ ͓͈͉̻͊ ̼͓̈́͌̓͑͆͐
͉͈̀ ͆ ͉͚͊͊̀ ͎͓ ͒̀ ͓͉͑͂͏̀͒̈́̾ ͏̼͈̈́ ͌̀ ͈̈́̾͌̀ ͚̀ ͋͆ ͔͉̈́͛͊̈́͒̀ ͓͈͉̻͊
͉͈͓̀͏͇͉͈͉̻̀͌̈́͒
̢͓͓͉͓͒̽͆͑͑̈́̽̓̈́͌͏̼͈͉͇͈̻͖͓̈́͌̀̈́͂̀̾͑͒̀͒̀͌͗͑̈́͂̈́̾̀
͓͊͌͒̽͏͈͓̀͊͌͒̽͏͈͈̻̀͒͗͌̽̀͏͚͎͈͓͉͓̼͋̈́͐͑͑̈́͐
̧̻͈͈́͑͆̈́͑͒͌̈́͒͜͏̼͈͎͎͇͇͚͎̻͚̼̈́͒̀͌̀͒̈́͒͆̈́̾͋͌͌͗̀͌̀
̀̈́͏͈͚͎͔͎͋̈́͌͛ͅ͏͎͎͓͈͎͓͉͉͓͌͒̾̓̀͒̀͑̈́̀͑͒̽
̥̻͉̻͚͈̻͈͎͎͇͇̼͔͎͌͒͗̀͋̀́͑͆̈́͑͒͌͒̈́͒͆̈́̾͌̀͐͛͜͏͎͎͌͐͋͏̈́̾
͎̻͕͎͎͓̻͉͎͓͒͐͒͂̈́͏͓͂̀͑̾̀͐͌̀̈́͏͈͎̻͕͈͎́̀̾͌̈́͒̈́͊͑͒
͈͎͎̻͕͎͓̼͈͎̰̀̀͒͛͋̈́͌͐͑̈́̀͒͐͒͐̓͆͂̾̈́͐͏͎̼͍͈͓͎͍͈͑͒̈́͒͐̓̈́̾̈́͐
͈͎͓͑͒͐̓͆͂̾̈́͐͑͌̀͏͎͚͎͓͔͎͋͊͂͆͑͆͐͒͛͏͎͓͌
̤͈͉̻͚͍̼̻͓͚͖͎͕͈̀͒͆͌̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆̈́͌͐̈́̀͂͗͂̀͊́̈́͒̈́͆͒̈́͂̈́͏͈͎̾̓
͉̻͈̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆͐̓̀͒͆͏̻̻͕͈͉̻͇͚͌͒̀͐͌͒̀͒͆͌̈́͊͑͒͆̈́͒͆̀͑͒̀͑͆͜
͚̻͈̥͈͉̀͒͆́͑͆̈́͑͒͌͜
̨̳͇͕͎͔͕͖͇͍͖͒͑͑͋̓́̓͑́͑͋͌
̪̻͈͉͎͈͔̻͈͌̈́͒̈́͋̀̽͑͒͆͌̈́͌̈́̀̈́͏͔͈͂̀͑̾̀͐͑͛͋͗͌̀͋̈́͒͐
͈͉͓͚͈̻͈̈́͌̓̈́͌͋̈́͌̈́͐̓̀͑͒͑̈́͐
̲̈́ ͍͈͛͊͌̈́͐ ͈͔̻͈̈́͌̈́̈́͐ ̈́͏͂̀͑̾̀͐ ́̈́͏͈͉͌͑͒̈́͜ ͈͒͐ ͈͔̻͈̈́͌̈́̈́͐ ͉͎̽͐ ͋̈́
͈͈͈͉͉͚͈͈͔͚͎͓͋̀̈́̓̽͊͊̀͂̀͌̀̓̀͑̀͊̾͑̈́͒̈́͒͆͑͒̈́͂̀͌͒͆͒̀͒͐
̨͏͎͇͔͓͕͓͆͋̾͑̾͑
̞͒̀͌ ͉̻͒͗ ͚̀ ͒͆ ̻́͑͆ ͈̈́͑͒͌͜ ̓̈́͌ ͉͇̈́͂̀͒̀͑͒̀̈́̾ ͉̼̀͌͌̀͐ ͔͎͛͏͎͌͐
͉͈̀̀͏̼͈͉̻͓̀͋͌̈́͆͒͗͒͆͐͊̈́͏̻͇̈́͊̈́͛̈́͏̀͏͎͈͑͒̽͏̼͈̈́͌̀
͏͎̼͍͍͑̈́͒̈́͒̀̈́̽͐
■ ̧ ͎͎͇̼͒͒͆͑͆ ͚̈́͌͐ ͈̻͎͓̈́͌̓͋̈́͑ ̻͎͓͒ ͉̻͒͗ ͚̀ ̻͈́͑̈́͐ ͈̈́͑͒͌͜ ͋̈́
͉͆͊̈́͒͏͈͉̼̻͉͈͐͊̈́͐͋̀͂̈́͏̼͎͉͓͋̀͒͐̽͋̈́̀͑͒̽͏̈́͐:RN͈̈́̾͌̀
͓͎͕͏͈͉̈́͗͒̽
■ ̧͎͎͇̼͚͈̻͎͓̻͎͓͉̻͚̻͈͈͒͒͆͑͆̈́͌͐̈́͌̓͋̈́͑͒͒͗̀́͑̈́͐̈́͑͒͌͜
̀̈́͏͎͓͕̾͗͏͉͓̾͐̀͑͒̽͏̀:RN͓͈͈͎͔͓͑͌̾͑͒̀͒̀͂̀͒͆͌̀͂̽͒͆͐
͔͇̈́̀̽͐͋̈́͒͆̈́͏͈͚͉̻͓͋̀͌͋̈́͌͆͒͗͊̈́͏̻̻͈͒͆͐́͑͆͐̈́͑͒͌͜
̟͖͎͎͎͇̼͐͒͒͆͑͆͐PP͚͉̻͓̀͒͆͌͒͗͊̈́͏̻̻͈͒͆͐́͑͆͐̈́͑͒͌͜
̴͈͉͚͎͓͈̻͎͓̻͎͓̬͔̼͍͈͎͓͈͉͚͈͊͒̈́͌̓͋̈́͑͒͆̀͌̀͊͋͊͂̀̀͏̻͈̓̈́͂͋̀
̼͎͉͎͋͒̀͊͊̽͌͒͏͉̼̀͊̀
̨̨͕͔͕͔͉͕͉͓͔͖͔͇͖͓͌̓̾̓͌̀͋͌ͅ
̷͇͉͆͋͐͝ ̤͈͎͎͇̼̻͈͕̀͒͆͌͒͒͆͑͆͒͆͐́͑͆͐̈́͑͒͌͜͏͈͎͎͈͆͑͋̽͑͒̈́
͏͎͓͈͉̻̻͈͑͒̀͒̈́͒͂͌͒̀
̢̻͎͎͎̼͎͎͈͉͚͌͊͂̀͋̈́͒͋͌͒͊͒͑͒̈́͂̀͌͗͒̀͏̼͓͈͋́͑͋̀͌̀̈́̾͌̀
͎͎͇̼͎͒̈́͒͆͋͌ ̽̓͆ ͉̻̀͒ ͒͆͌ ̼͍͎͎̓ ͚̀ ͎͒ ̈́͏͎̻͈͎͂͑͒͑ ̲̈́ ͓̀͒̽͌ ͒͆͌