■ *NPCJMJBJODBTTPEFWPOPFTTFSFSFTJTUFOUJBUFNQFSBUVSFGJOPB
z$
4F JM QJBOP EJ DPUUVSB ¨ FMFUUSJDP P NJTUP HBT FE FMFUUSJDJU F OPO D¨
VOGPSOPOFMMB[POBTPUUPTUBOUFDPMMPDBSFVOTFQBSBUPSFEJ
NBUFSJBMF OPO JOGJBNNBCJMF BE FT NFUBMMP P MFHOP DPNQFOTBUP B
NNEBMMBCBTFEFMQJBOPEJDPUUVSB*OUBMNPEPTFOF
JNQFEJTDFMBDDFTTPBMMBQBSUFJOGFSJPSF4FJMQJBOPEJDPUUVSB¨B
HBTTJSBDDPNBOEBEJDPMMPDBSFJMTFQBSBUPSFBMMBTUFTTBEJTUBO[B
4VJQJBOJEJMBWPSPJOMFHOPSJGJOJSFMFTVQFSGJDJEJUBHMJPDPOVOB
DPMMBTQFDJBMFQFSQSPUFHHFSMFEBMMVNJEJU
,QVWDOOD]LRQHGHOODSSDUHFFKLR
$,QVWDOOD]LRQHQRUPDOHILJ D
"TFDPOEBEFMNPEFMMPMBHVBSOJ[JPOFBEFTJWBQV²FTTFSF
BQQMJDBUBJOGBCCSJDB*OUBMDBTPOPOSJNVPWFSMBQFSOFTTVO
NPUJWPMBHVBSOJ[JPOFBEFTJWBFWJUBMFJOGJMUSB[JPOJ4FMB
HVBSOJ[JPOFOPO¨BQQMJDBUBJOGBCCSJDBJODPMMBSMBTVMCPSEP
JOGFSJPSFEFMQJBOPEJDPUUVSB
1FSJMGJTTBHHJPEFMMBQQBSFDDIJPBMNPCJMFEJJODBTTP
&TUSBSSFMFHSBGGFEBMTBDDIFUUPEFHMJBDDFTTPSJFBWWJUBSMFOFMMB
QPTJ[JPOFJOEJDBUBMBTDJBOEPDIFHJSJOPMJCFSBNFOUF
*ODBTTBSFFDFOUSBSFJMQJBOPEJDPUUVSB
1SFNFSFTVJCPSEJGJOPBEBQQPHHJBSFQFSGFUUBNFOUFUVUUPJM
QFSJNFUSP
(JSBSFMFHSBGGFFTUSJOHFSMFBGPOEP
-BQPTJ[JPOFEFMMFHSBGGFEJQFOEFEBMMPTQFTTPSFEFMQJBOPEJ
MBWPSP
%,QVWDOOD]LRQHDILORILJ E
&TFHVJSFMJOTUBMMB[JPOFOPSNBMFEFMMBQQBSFDDIJPBTTJDVSBOEPTJ
DIF JOUPSOP BE FTTP DJ TJB VOP TQB[JP VOJGPSNF *M QJBOP EJ DPUUVSB
EFWFSFTUBSFMFHHFSNFOUFBMEJTPUUPEFMMBTVQFSGJDJFEJMBWPSP
1FSQJBOJEJMBWPSPEJQJBTUSFMMFTFOFDFTTBSJPTPMMFWBSFMF
TVQFSGJDJEJBQQPHHJPDPOMJTUPOJSFTJTUFOUJBMMBUFNQFSBUVSBF
BMMBDRVB
7FSJGJDBSFJMGVO[JPOBNFOUPFMBQPTJ[JPOFEFMMBQQBSFDDIJP
3JFNQJSF MP TQB[JP USB JM QJBOP EJ MBWPSP FE JM QJBOP EJ DPUUVSB DPO
PQQPSUVOBDPMMBBMTJMJDPOFUSBEJ[JPOBMFOFMDPMPSFEFTJEFSBUP
$YYHUWHQ]D 4F TJ VUJMJ[[B DPMMB BM TJMJDPOF JOBQQSPQSJBUB TV QJBOJ
DPUUVSBJOQJFUSBOBUVSBMFQPUSFCCFSPQSPEVSTJDPMPSB[JPOJ
JNQPTTJCJMJEBFMJNJOBSFQPTTJCJMFBDRVJTUBSFMBDPMMB
BQQSPQSJBUBDPOUBUUBOEPJMOPTUSP4FSWJ[JPEJBTTJTUFO[BUFDOJDB
DPEJDF5FOFSFJODPOTJEFSB[JPOFMFJOEJDB[JPOJEJVTP
EFMGBCCSJDBOUF
4QJBOBSF MB DPMMB BM TJMJDPOF QSJNB DIF TJ GPSNJ VOP TUSBUP DPO VO
SBTDIJFUUPPDPOJMEJUPJOVNJEJUJDPOTBQPOF
-BTDJBSBTDJVHBSFMBDPMMBBMTJMJDPOFQSJNBEJVUJMJ[[BSF
MBQQBSFDDIJP
6PRQWDJJLRGHOSLDQRGLFRWWXUD
4DPMMFHBSFMBQQBSFDDIJPEBMMFQSFTFFMFUUSJDIFFEBMMBUUBDDPEFM
HBT
4WJUBSFMFHSBGGFFTFHVJSFJONPEPJOWFSTPMBQSPDFEVSBEJ
NPOUBHHJP
$WWDFFRGHOJDVILJ
-FTUSFNJUEFMMBDPOOFTTJPOFEJJOHSFTTPEFMQJBOPEJDPUUVSBB
HBT¨EPUBUBEJGJMFUUBUVSBEBࣔ NNDIFDPOTFOUF
■ JMDPMMFHBNFOUPSJHJEP
■ MBUUBDDPBVOUVCPGMFTTJCJMFNFUBMMJDP- NJO NNBY N
OFDFTTBSJPJOUFSDBMBSFMBHVBSOJ[JPOFEJUFOVUBJO
EPUB[JPOFGSBMVTDJUBEFMDPMMFUUPSFFJMSBDDPSEPEFMHBT
4JEFWFFWJUBSFJMDPOUBUUPEFMUVCPDPOQBSUJNPCJMJEFMMVOJU
EJODBTTPBEFTFNQJPVODBTTFUUPFJMQBTTBHHJPBUUSBWFSTP
TQB[JTPHHFUUJBQPTTJCJMJPTUSV[JPOJ
*ORVBMTJBTJDPOOFTTJPOF QRQPXRYHUHQpJLUDUHLOJRPLWR EBMMB
QPTJ[JPOFTUBCJMJUBJOGBCCSJDB
/FMDBTPJODVJPDDPSSBSFBMJ[[BSFVOBDPOOFTTJPOFDJMJOESJDB
TPTUJUVJSFJMHPNJUPNPOUBUPJOGBCCSJDBDPORVFMMPGPSOJUPOFM
TBDDIFUUPEFHMJBDDFTTPSJ'JH B
/POTDPSEBSTJEJJOUFSDBMBSFMBHVBSOJ[JPOF
: 3HULFRORGLIXJKH
4FTJNBOJQPMBRVBMVORVFUJQPEJSBDDPSEPWFSJGJDBSOFMBUFOVUB
*MGBCCSJDBOUFEFDMJOBPHOJSFTQPOTBCJMJUJODBTPEJDPOOFTTJPOJ
DIFQSFTFOUJOPGVHIFEPQPMBNBOJQPMB[JPOFEFMMFTUFTTF
&RQQHVVLRQHHOHWWULFDILJ
7FSJGJDBSFDIFMBUFOTJPOFFMBQPUFO[BEFMMBQQBSFDDIJPTJBOP
DPNQBUJCJMJDPOMJNQJBOUPFMFUUSJDP
* QJBOJ EJ DPUUVSB WFOHPOP GPSOJUJ EPUBUJ EJ DBWP EJ BMJNFOUB[JPOF DPO
PTFO[BTQJOBFMFUUSJDB
(MJBQQBSFDDIJNVOJUJEJTQJOBEFWPOPFTTFSFDPMMFHBUJTPMUBOUPB
QSFTFFMFUUSJDIFDPOQSFTBEJUFSSBEFCJUBNFOUFJOTUBMMBUF
1SFWFEFSFVOTF[JPOBUPSFPOOJQPMBSFDPOBQFSUVSBEJDPOUBUUPEJ
BMNFOP NNUSBOOFDIFQFSJDPMMFHBNFOUJBTQJOBTFMVUFOUF
QV²BDDFEFSWJ
2VFTUPBQQBSFDDIJP¨EFMUJQP࣓:ࣔ*MDBWPEJJOHSFTTPOPOQV²
FTTFSF DBNCJBUP EBMMVUFOUF NB TPMP EBM 4FSWJ[JP 5FDOJDP 0DDPSSF
JOGBUUJSJTQFUUBSFJMUJQPEJDBWPFMBTF[JPOFNJOJNB
&DPELRGHOWLSRGLJDV
4FMBOPSNBUJWBEFMQBFTFMPDPOTFOUFRVFTUPBQQBSFDDIJPQV²
FTTFSFBEBUUBUPBEBMUSJUJQJEJHBTWUBSHBJEFOUJGJDBUJWB*
DPNQPOFOUJOFDFTTBSJBRVFTUBPQFSB[JPOFTJUSPWBOPOFMMBCPSTB
LJUEJDPOWFSTJPOFJOEPUB[JPOFBTFDPOEBEFMNPEFMMPP
EJTQPOJCJMFQSFTTPJMOPTUSP4FSWJ[JP5FDOJDP1SPDFEFSFDPNF
JOEJDBUPEJTFHVJUP
$6RVWLWX]LRQHGHJOLLQLHWWRULILJ
3JNVPWFSFMFHSJHMJFJDPQFSDIJEFMCSVDJBUPSFFJEJGGVTPSJ
4PTUJUVJSFHMJJOJFUUPSJVTBOEPMBDIJBWFEJTQPOJCJMFQSFTTPJM
OPTUSP4FSWJ[JP5FDOJDPDPEJDFQFSJCSVDJBUPSJ
BEPQQJBPUSJQMBGJBNNBGBSSJGFSJNFOUPBMMBUBCFMMB **GBDFOEP
QBSUJDPMBSF BUUFO[JPOF DIF MJOJFUUPSF OPO TJ EJTUBDDIJ RVBOEP UPMUP
PGJTTBUPBMCSVDJBUPSF
"TTJDVSBSTJEJTFSSBSMJBGPOEPQFSHBSBOUJSOFMBUFOVUB
*ORVFTUJCSVDJBUPSJOPO¨OFDFTTBSJPFGGFUUVBSFMBSFHPMB[JPOF
EFMMBSJBQSJNBSJB
$PMMPDBSFJEJGGVTPSJFJDPQFSDIJEFJCSVDJBUPSJTVJDPSSJTQPOEFOUJ
GVPDIJ4JEFWPOPJOPMUSFQPTJ[JPOBSFBEFHVBUBNFOUFMFHSJHMJF
TVHMJBQQPTJUJFMFNFOUJEJTPTUFHOP
%5HJROD]LRQHGHLUXELQHWWL
$PMMPDBSFMFNBOPQPMFOFMMBQPTJ[JPOFEJNJOJNP
&TUSBSSFMFNBOPQPMFEFJSVCJOFUUJ'JH
4JUSPWFSVOBUFOVUBJOHPNNBGMFTTJCJMFTVGGJDJFOUFGBSF
QSFTTJPOFDPOMBQVOUBEFMDBDDJBWJUFQFSDSFBSFTQB[JPF
BDDFEFSFBMMBWJUFEJSFHPMB[JPOFEFMSVCJOFUUP 1RQVPRQWDUH
PDLODWHQXWD
3FHPMBSFJMGVPDPNJOJNPHJSBOEPMBWJUFEJCZQBTTDPOVO
DBDDJBWJUFBQVOUBQJBUUB
" TFDPOEB EFM HBT VUJMJ[[BUP EBMMBQQBSFDDIJP W UBCFMMB *** BHJSF
EJDPOTFHVFO[B
"TUSJOHFSFBGPOEPMFWJUJEJCZQBTT
# BMMFOUBSF MF WJUJ EJ CZQBTT GJOP BMMB DPSSFUUB SFHPMB[JPOF EFM HBT
JOVTDJUBEBJCSVDJBUPSJWFSJGJDBSFDIFSFHPMBOEPMBNBOPQPMBUSB
JMNBTTJNPFJMNJOJNPJMCSVDJBUPSFOPOTJTQFOHBO©TJ
WFSJGJDIJOPSJUPSOJEJGJBNNB
$MFWJUJEJCZQBTTEFWPOPFTTFSFTPTUJUVJUFEBVOUFDOJDP
BVUPSJ[[BUP
%OPONBOJQPMBSFMFWJUJEJCZQBTT
4F OPO TJ SJFTDF BE BDDFEFSF BMMB WJUF EJ CZQBTT TNPOUBSF MB QBSUF
TVQFSJPSFEFMQJBOPEJDPUUVSBGJTTBUBBMSFTUPEFMQJBOPEJDPUUVSB
EBVOTJTUFNBEJWJUJ1FSSJNVPWFSMBQSPDFEFSFDPNFTFHVF
5PHMJFSFUVUUFMFHSJHMJFJDPQFSDIJEFJCSVDJBUPSJJEJGGVTPSJFMF
NBOPQPMF
3JNVPWFSFMFWJUJEFJCSVDJBUPSJ
1FSSJNPOUBSFMBQQBSFDDIJPJOWFSUJSFMBQSPDFEVSBEJ
TNPOUBHHJP
1FS HBSBOUJSF MB UFOVUB ¨ JNQPSUBOUF DIF WXWWH MF UFOVUF TJBOP BM
MPSPQPTUP2VFTUJFMFNFOUJTPOPJOEJTQFOTBCJMJQFSJMDPSSFUUP
GVO[JPOBNFOUPEFMMBQQBSFDDIJPEBUPDIFJNQFEJTDPOP
MJOUSPEV[JPOFEJMJRVJEJFTQPSDJ[JBBMMJOUFSOPEFMMBQQBSFDDIJP
/POTNPOUBSFNBJMBTTFEFMSVCJOFUUP'JH JODBTPEJHVBTUP
TPTUJUVJSFJMSVCJOFUUPDPNQMFUP
$WWHQ]LRQH
"MUFSNJOFBQQMJDBSFMFUJDIFUUBBEFTJWBJOEJDBOEPJMOVPWPUJQPEJ
HBTBDDBOUPBMMBUBSHBJEFOUJGJDBUJWB
nl
é
,QVWDOODWLHYRRUVFKULIW
9HLOLJKHLGVDDQZLM]LQJHQ
-FFTEFJOTUSVDUJFTWBOIFUBQQBSBBUBMWPSFOTPWFSUFHBBOUPUEF
JOTUBMMBUJFFOIFUHFCSVJLFSWBO
%FHSBGJFLFOBGHFCFFMEJOEJU*OTUBMMBUJFWPPSTDISJGU[JKOUFS
PSJ«OUBUJF
'HIDEULNDQWLVYULMYDQHONHYHUDQWZRRUGHOLMNKHLGLQGLHQQLHW
YROGDDQZRUGWDDQGHEHVFKLNNLQJHQYDQGH]HKDQGOHLGLQJ
$OOHZHUN]DDPKHGHQEHWUHIIHQGHLQVWDOODWLHDIVWHOOLQJHQ
DDQSDVVLQJDDQHHQDQGHUJDVW\SHPRHWHQZRUGHQ